Great game with tons of replay value. Most of the negative reviews cite the inaccurate rangefinding of radar. This is true. Use the map instead - it is hyper-accurate. On your first shot use whatever to radar suggests. After that, bring your ships broadside and to a halt. Check the map for each shot after. Youll quickly get the hang of how much to modify the elevation to get hits every time. Ive 3 starred every mission and won the battle of the atlantic on both sides easily using this.
I think it would be boring if it were automatic. In true sims like Silent Hunter series, youre constantly accessing the map and using skill to beat the game.
BTW this is best played on big screens like iPads or iphone 6+. I tried on iphone 5 and its a little too small for me.
Gotodengo about Atlantic Fleet, v1.11